I enjoyed this Forbes article that asks if robotics is going to be the next tech bubble:
Robots will be a very big thing, and soon. What holds them back is what stunts most technology: a walled-garden approach to their systems. Robots currently do what the designers want them to do and that's it. Gadgets and gimmicks and concept robots from huge corporations all presage the moment that open-architecture robots will catapult robotics out of its niche. [...]
There is actually no technical barrier to start this wave. All that is required is the right marketing idea at the right moment. There have already been a series of near misses, from the Tandy Armatron years ago to Lego Mindstorms--a Lego set that combined electric motors and sensors with programmable Lego bricks.
They compare robotics to the computing industry: computers of course started out as large, highly specialized tools that weren't accessible to the average consumer, then the PC arrived and sparked an entire industry as users got their hands on them and developed the useful applications that make computers essential to today's lifestyle. So will this happen to robots?
Compare this to the computing industry analogy that was brought up last year at an MIT Museum event: the idea that just as we don't think of our ovens and cars as computers, they are; and just as we may not think of the kitchens and cars of the future as robots, they will be.
So is "open architecture" the answer, as the article suggests? Should I go ahead and establish the OLPC (One LEGOMindstorm Per Child) program to see what the budding robot geeks can do? Maybe more specialized component platforms -- Microsoft's Robotics Studio, for example -- will be the key, just as so many Web 2.0 services depend on AJAX. Who are the killer apps going to come from?

Automaton
Comments (2)
Thanks for the article. I have been working on a book concerning the potential impact an automated transport system, essentially the driverless car, will have on society. It seems to me that this is the killer app that will be where robots have their greatest medium term impact. I would love to make contact with anyone willing to discuss the subject, especially knowledgeable skeptics. Feel free to contact me at sila332@gmail.com. Lars
Posted by lars | March 5, 2008 8:38 AM
What most "experts" who make such predictions do not appear to realize is that there is a major limiting factor: Algorithms!
We have the sensors, computers, and actuators. However, except for the most trivial applications (Roomba), what is missing is the sophisticated algorithms and corresponding software/FPGAs to make this happen. Only then will the economies of mass production follow.
Empty standards and frameworks such as MS Robotics Studio really don't supply this missing element, and it isn't going to be magically developed by small school children, either.
Posted by Nelson Bridwell | March 6, 2008 5:48 PM